Philadelphia Eagles 2012 Draft: 2nd and 3rd Round QBs Have a Low Success Rate | Eagles Addict

If the Philadelphia Eagles are thinking about drafting a quarterback in round two or three of the 2012 NFL draft, it might behoove them to reconsider that idea.

I posted this a few weeks ago but it’s worth repeating since the buzz about the Eagles drafting a QB early is gaining steam.  Dan Pompei of the National Football Post reported recently the following:

A buzz is building in NFL front offices that the Eagles are going to take a quarterback fairly high. If they don’t make a move for Ryan Tannehill in round one, the Eagles could wait until the second round and go after Kirk Cousins or Brandon Weeden. Such a move could indicate the Eagles have concerns about Michael Vick’s ability to stay healthy and how he fits in Andy Reid’s offense.

The Eagles are, in fact, showing a lot of interest in this year’s QB class prospects.  Either through combine or Senior Bowl interviews, private workouts or private visits, they’ve already been linked to several players such as Kirk Cousins, Ryan Tannehill, Ryan Lindley, Nick Foles, Brock Osweiler and Russell Wilson.

They were even rumored to be interested in trading up to the No. 2 overall pick in order to snare Robert Griffin III.

Ryan Tannehill
Would it be worth it to trade up for Tannehill? Photo:

When the Eagles show a lot of interest in players of a certain position leading up to the draft, it means there is a good chance they are looking at drafting a player at that position.  For example, prior to the draft last year the position the Eagles were linked to the most was linebacker (pre-draft visits, private workouts, general interest, etc).

They ended up drafting three of them (Casey Matthews, Brian Rolle and Greg Lloyd).

Therefore, given their level of interest in QBs so far this year, it appears there is a good chance the Eagles are strongly considering drafting one.  The question is, at what point in the draft would they pull the trigger?

Anymore these days, QBs are severely over-drafted due to the high demand and lack of quality supply at the position.  This means that, if the Eagles want one of the “second tier” quarterbacks, they will very likely have to use a second or third-round draft pick on one.

QBs Andrew Luck and RG3 will go Nos 1 and 2 and then Ryan Tannehill will go somewhere in the top 10.  After them, there is a clump of second-tier guys who are slated to go between the second and fourth rounds.

However, given the fact that this is a QB-needy league, the best, if not all, of these second-tier guys will be drafted between the second and third rounds because teams cannot afford to wait and gamble that their target will be there later.

So, one can come to a relatively certain conclusion that if the Eagles want a quarterback with any kind of potential, they’ll have to spend one of their top picks.

The problem is, it’s simply not worth it.  And here’s why:

Disregarding the 2011 draft (because it’s too soon to judge), out of the last 15 drafts there have been a grand total of 34 quarterbacks taken in either the second or third round.

Out of those 34 QBs, only three…I repeat, three…have played at a level I’d be comfortable with as my starting quarterback.  They are: Drew Brees, Matt Schaub and Jake Plummer.

Here is the full list of second and third-round QBs taken between 1996 and 2010:

Tony Banks – 2nd

Bobby Hoying – 3rd

Jake Plummer – 2nd

Charlie Batch – 2nd

Jonathan Quinn – 3rd

Brian Griese – 3rd

Shaun King – 2nd

Brock Huard – 3rd

Giovanni Carmazzi – 3rd

Chris Redman – 3rd

Drew Brees – 2nd

Quincy Carter – 2nd

Marques Tuiasosopo – 2nd

Josh McCown – 3rd

Dave Ragone – 3rd

Chris Simms- 3rd

Matt Schaub – 3rd

Charlie Frye – 3rd

Andrew Walter – 3rd

David Greene – 3rd

Kellen Clemens – 2nd

Tarvaris Jackson – 2nd

Charlie Whitehurst – 3rd

Brodie Croyle – 3rd

Kevin Kolb – 2nd

John Beck – 2nd

Drew Stanton – 2nd

Trent Edwards – 3rd

Brian Brohm – 2nd

Chad Henne – 2nd

Kevin O’Connell – 3rd

Pat White – 2nd

Jimmy Clausen – 2nd

Colt McCoy – 3rd

A rather unimpressive list, is it not?

If you want to consider some of them as viable backups, that’s fine, there are a few those on that list.  However, only three of them ended up being a worthwhile starter.

So if you’re looking for your “quarterback of the future” in these rounds, history shows they have about a 9% success rate.  Not very favorable odds if you ask me.

Furthermore, if you look around the NFL at all of the starting QBs as of the end of the 2011 season, 19 (59%) of them were first round selections.  Then, if you only look at the QBs ranked in the top 15 (going by, 10 (66%) of them were first-rounders.

Even more telling is the fact that there are more late-round and undrafted free agents who are having more success than second and third rounders since 1996.  Tom Brady, Tony Romo, Ryan Fitzpatrick, Marc Bulger, Matt Cassel and Matt Hasselbeck are, or have been, successful starters in the NFL.

That’s more than twice as many as the second and third rounders!

Therefore, we can conclude that Trent Edwards and Mike Kafka are just as good of a backup to Michael Vick as any second or third-rounder will be.  And furthermore, there seems to be better odds at finding a future starter late in the draft than there is in these rounds.

Do the Eagles need to think about the future at the quarterback position?  Yes, they do.

However, the reality is that for them to get one of quality, they will have to go through a miserable losing season in order to draft a good one with a high first round pick.

Either that or they would have to consider moving up into the top 10 of this draft in order to land Tannehill.  However, they would have to give up too much to do so and it would pretty much solidify Andy Reid as head coach for the next five years regardless of what happens.

I understand that quarterback is the most important position on an NFL team.  It’s a position of great demand with a very short supply and teams have to take chances on prospects with some potential.

Andy Reid likes to rebuild his team gradually and on the fly.  The last thing he wants to do is suffer a 3-13 season to put them in a draft postion to get a blue-chip QB prospect.  This is why he probably will end up taking a QB in the second or third round.

However, my main point here is that it likely won’t be worth it if a future starter is what they seek.  It would just be wasting a good draft pick on a position that has a very low chance of ever paying off.

Category: Eagles Related

About the Author

Comments are closed.

Subscribe to Eagles Addict!

  • Twitter
  • RSS Feed
  • Facebook


How will the Eagles do this season?

View Results

Loading ... Loading ...